Transcript
[0:00] Hello, friends!
[0:01] 10th March 1959,
[0:03] The Chinese Government invited the Dalai Lama
[0:06] to attend a special Chinese theatre performance.
[0:09] But their invitation was accompanied by a strange demand.
[0:13] They asked the Dalai Lama to attend the performance,
[0:17] but without his bodyguards.
[0:19] This alarmed the people.
[0:21] People wondered if the Chinese government
[0:24] was trying to kidnap the Dalai Lama.
[0:27] Or to arrest him,
or even maybe, assassinate him?
[0:29] The thing was, some days before this,
[0:32] the Chinese government had sent their soldiers to Tibet's capital Lhasa.
[0:36] The city was surrounded by the Chinese military by then.
[0:40] The Dalai Lama lived in this city.
[0:43] This beautiful palace was his residence.
[0:45] The Potala Palace.
[0:46] As soon as the followers of the Dalai Lama and the Tibetian citizens
[0:49] found out about this invitation,
[0:51] there was a big uprising.
[0:53] People came out of their homes and surrounded the palace.
[0:57] They were willing to protect their leader at all costs.
[1:00] Tensions were rising.
[1:02] The communication between the Chinese authorities
[1:04] and the government led by Dalai Lama was broken.
[1:07] The threat had progressed to such levels that
[1:09] there was no reasonable chance of the Dalai Lama's escape.
[1:12] During this, about 7 days later, on 17th March 1959,
[1:16] Dalai Lama went undercover.
[1:19] He put on a disguise and escaped the palace.
[1:22] And just like that,
[1:24] the Chinese army invaded and took control of this once-sovereign country.
[1:28] Friends, this is the story of a sovereign Tibet.
[1:31] That existed once upon a time.
[1:33] A great country occupied by China.
[1:36] How did this happen?
[1:37] Come, let's try to understand this in today's video.
[1:42] "High in the Himalayas,
[1:44] Tibet has through the centuries,
[1:46] preserved its own ways and customs.
[1:50] Tibet's religious tradition is personified by the Dalai Lama.
[1:54] Revered by his people as the living Buddha."
[1:58] "The image of a leader whose efforts of conciliation,
[2:01] had met with brutal contempt by Communist China."
[2:09] Friends, if you look at the history,
[2:10] there were 3 provinces in Tibet.
[2:12] Look at the map,
[2:13] U-Tsang, Amdo, and Kham.
[2:16] These existed since the Tibetian Empire.
[2:18] The combined area of these provinces happened to be huge!
[2:22] Almost 2.5 million km².
[2:25] Archaeological evidence shows us that humans
[2:27] had been living in the Eastern Tibetian areas for 4,000- 5,000 years.
[2:32] The Tibetian civilisation is actually very old.
[2:35] But this area was unified around the 7th century AD,
[2:40] by the Yarlung Dynasty.
[2:42] This was done by Namri Songtsen, and his son Songtsen Gampo.
[2:46] Credited as the founder of the Tibetian Empire.
[2:49] During this era, border disputes between China and Tibet began.
[2:53] By China, I mean the then Kingdom in China
[2:56] and the then Kingdom in Tibet.
[2:58] There were border disputes between them.
[3:00] But in the year 821, a formal peace treaty was signed
[3:04] by the Chinese and Tibetian kingdoms
[3:06] to clearly define the borders
[3:08] and to ensure that Tibetans remain happy in Tibet,
[3:12] and the Chinese remain happy in China.
[3:14] This was an important time in Tibetan history
[3:17] because, during this time, Buddhism entered Tibet.
[3:21] King Gampo had two Buddhist wives,
[3:23] One from Nepal and another from China.
[3:25] It's said that they influenced him to adopt Buddhism.
[3:29] But there was a strong push among the Tibetans
[3:32] when King Trisong Detsen ascended to the throne,
[3:36] He ruled from the years 755 AD to 797 AD.
[3:40] An Indian teacher is credited here.
[3:45] He was invited from India to Tibet.
[3:47] Tibetan Buddhism began mainly due to him.
[3:51] Today, he is known as Guru Rinpoche by Tibetans.
[3:55] Around then, Nalanda University's head Shantarakshita
[3:58] was invited to Tibet to teach Buddhism.
[4:01] But returning to geopolitics,
[4:03] in the year 1240, Mongols invaded Tibet.
[4:06] In 1247, Ghenghis Khan's grandson, Godan Khan,
[4:11] Met a Tibetan Lama Sakya Pandita,
[4:15] Under his influence, Godan Khan adopted Buddhism.
[4:19] Friends, this religion emphasises the concept of learning a lot.
[4:23] Buddhism talks about introspection.
[4:26] To continue learning.
[4:27] But, I'd like to tell you an important thing here
[4:30] Tibetan Buddhism is a bit different from mainstream Buddhism.
[4:34] A new, interesting concept developed in Tibetan Buddhism.
[4:38] Tibetans started believing that the teachers who teach us,
[4:42] the compassionate teachers keep being reincarnated.
[4:45] They are reborn.
[4:46] And in each of their births, we can identify them when they are young,
[4:51] And once identified, they should be brought to Lhasa,
[4:55] and given the same prestige, they received in their previous life.
[4:59] Friends, these teachers are known as the Lamas.
[5:01] In Tibet, there are many such Lamas,
[5:04] on various levels of hierarchy.
[5:06] At the top, is the Dalai Lama.
[5:08] Considered the most important teacher.
[5:11] For their culture, and their religion.
[5:13] Moving on with our story, in 1720,
[5:15] the next major invasion of Tibet took place.
[5:17] This time, by the Qing Dynasty in China.
[5:20] In this invasion, two provinces of Tibet, Kham and Amdo,
[5:25] were turned Chinese in all aspects by this dynasty.
[5:29] They were renamed Qinghai in 1724.
[5:33] Yup, and just like that, Tibet lost these two provinces to China.
[5:39] The remaining region of Tibet
[5:41] acted as a tributary state to the Qing Dynasty.
[5:44] They remained independent to some extent
[5:46] but were under the indirect influence of the dynasty.
[5:49] The Qing Dynasty ended in 1912
[5:52] when the Xinhai Revolution took place in China
[5:54] and the Republic of China was born.
[5:58] Meanwhile, all of the Chinese troops were thrown out of Lhasa.
[6:03] The then Dalai Lama said,
[6:08] Clearly emphasising the independence of Tibet.
[6:12] But it didn't mean that the newly formed Chinese government
[6:15] accepted Tibet's sovereignty.
[6:17] China wanted to continue asserting its influence.
[6:19] The new Chinese government also claimed Tibet.
[6:23] The British had to get involved to solve this dispute.
[6:26] They asked them to come to Shimla and have a conference.
[6:30] To get to a solution through discussions.
[6:33] The conference was held in 1914,
[6:35] Representatives of Britain, China, and Tibet came together,
[6:39] But they couldn't get to any conclusions.
[6:41] China did not sign the Shimla Convention,
[6:43] But the British and the Tibetans did.
[6:45] This helps develop friendship between the two countries.
[6:47] Over the next 40 years,
[6:49] Tibet continues to be an Independent country.
[6:52] Completely free and autonomous.
[6:55] Between 1912 and 1950,
there were no foreign influences.
[7:00] Everything was calm and people were peacefully living in Tibet.
[7:03] And then came a big twist in our story in 1949.
[7:07] Under Mao Zedong, the Communist revolution was seen in China.
[7:11] The ROC government was pushed to Taiwan.
[7:14] And the People's Republic of China was born, PRC.
[7:18] I talked about this in detail in the video on Taiwan.
[7:21] Mao Zedong's People's Liberation Army
[7:23] defeated the ROC's army.
[7:25] And the China that we know today, was born.
[7:28] Mao Zedong threatens Tibet,
[7:31] that he will liberate Tibet
[7:32] and integrate it with Motherland.
[7:34] In 1950, an announcement was made on Radio Beijing.
[7:44] The army was given a task for the year,
"Tibet's Liberation".
[7:49] Where liberation actually meant Occupation.
[7:52] "Mao revived China's old imperial ambitions
[7:56] to impose its sovereignty on Tibet.
[7:59] To force the Tibetan authorities,
[8:00] to admit that the Chinese forces
marching upon their country
[8:04] were not an army of conquers,
[8:06] but an army of liberation from Western Imperialism."
[8:10] Mao Zedong was a staunch communist.
[8:12] He was strictly against all religions.
[8:14] He wanted no religions and no hierarchies.
[8:17] And he believed that Tibet was a part of China.
[8:20] During his win, a very important Tibetan person showed their support.
[8:27] The 10th Panchen Lama.
[8:29] As I told you, the Dalai Lama is at the top of the hierarchy,
[8:32] in Tibetan Buddhism, the Dalai Lama is the apex,
[8:35] Friends, the Panchen Lama is the immediate subordinate of the Dalai Lama.
[8:39] He is at the second spot.
[8:41] The then Panchen Lama had said that
[8:43] they were excited to see that the People's Liberation Army had won in China.
[8:48] And that they wanted Tibet's Liberation,
[8:50] on the behalf of the entire Tibetan people
[8:53] he asked China to accept his supreme respect and support.
[8:56] This new twist in the story may surprise you.
[8:58] Why would a Tibetan Lama support the Chinese Communist government?
[9:02] Friends, there is a simple reason for this.
[9:04] Actually, the 10th Panchen Lama
[9:07] was given his position by the Republic of China government.
[9:11] The government in Lhasa had chosen someone else
[9:14] but the ROC government gave this position to someone else.
[9:18] ROC had done this so that he could be in opposition to the PRC.
[9:22] But when Mao's PRC won in 1949, he started supporting PRC.
[9:28] Basically, he was a Chinese puppet.
[9:30] Neither the Tibetan people nor the Tibetan government had any influence on him.
[9:35] Oh, I forgot to tell you one important thing,
[9:37] The Panchen Lama was actually 12 years old then.
[9:41] So you can imagine the agency he might have had.
[9:45] On 1st January 1950,
[9:47] the People's Republic of China declared national sovereignty of the Tibetan regions.
[9:51] And as proof, they used the statement of the 12-year-old boy.
[9:56] After this, the Chinese government demanded
[9:59] that the Tibetan government send their representatives to Beijing.
[10:02] By 16th September 1950.
[10:04] The Tibetan officials ignore this demand.
[10:07] They assumed that even if the Chinese government claimed
[10:11] Tibet to be theirs
[10:13] they do not have to pay heed to it.
[10:16] But the Chinese government's demand was more of a threat.
[10:20] Within a month, on 7th October 1950,
[10:24] The soldiers of the Chinese army invaded Tibet.
[10:29] "The troops came from all over."
[10:34] By crossing the Yangtze river,
[10:35] they entered the eastern provinces of Tibet.
[10:38] And captured the city of Chamdo within two weeks.
[10:41] It is estimated that they were around 40,000 to 80,000 soldiers of the Chinese Army.
[10:46] Imagine this, when the population of Tibet back then was only 1 million.
[10:51] A huge area with a low density of population.
[10:55] In such an area, sending an army of 40,000-80,000 soldiers to a city.
[11:00] They used such brute force to invade.
[11:03] After this invasion, there was much uproar in Tibet.
[11:06] Tensions were rising.
[11:07] The 14th Dalai Lama had to become the head of the state of Tibet at a young age.
[11:14] At the age of only 15 years.
[11:15] From the perspective of Tibetans, it was necessary to do so,
[11:18] because, in Tibet, the figure of the Dalai Lama is very important.
[11:22] The most important spiritual figure, and their leader.
[11:25] If the position of the leader was vacant,
[11:33] In the General Assembly of the United Nations,
[11:36] this invasion was discussed, and on 18th November 1950,
[11:40] the United Nations officially condemned the Chinese invasion.
[11:45] But since the United Nations doesn't have an army
[11:47] that it could send to China to fight China,
[11:50] So there weren't many changes on the ground.
[11:53] But there was a change in China's strategy.
[11:55] Even though the Chinese military was at an advantageous position,
[11:59] they had established almost total control.
[12:02] China wanted to show the world
that they weren't forcefully occupying the area,
[12:07] So to do that, to manintain the 'legitimacy' of their claim,
[12:10] China called the Tibetian officials to negotiate.
[12:14] In 1951, Tibet sent a delegation to Beijing,
[12:19] But in Beijing, the Chinese government presented a lengthy document
[12:22] and asked them to sign it.
[12:24] That was the agreement that they had to sign.
[12:26] The delegation wasn't given a chance to consult with the Dalai Lama,
[12:31] or to consult the Tibetan government.
[12:33] They were forced to sign the document.
[12:36] What was the document?
[12:38] It was the Agreement of the Central People's Government
[12:41] and the Local Government of Tibet
[12:42] on Measures for the Peaceful Liberation of Tibet.
[12:44] Later shortened to be known as
the 17-point Agreement.
[12:48] The first point of the agreement was a bit scary for the Tibetans.
[12:52] The first point states that
[12:53] "The Tibetan people shall unite and...
[12:55] ...shall return to the family of
the Motherland,
[12:58] the People's Republic of China"
[12:59] The rest of the point makes it seem like
[13:02] China's actions were justified in some way.
[13:04] Because the other points mention that Tibet would be given autonomy.
[13:08] Buddhism would be respected,
[13:10] And the existing political system of Tibet,
[13:13] won't be changed by the Chinese government.
[13:15] The positions and powers of the Dalai Lama would continue.
[13:18] Friends, this is why people do not protest.
[13:21] The Tibetans actually start to accommodate the Chinese government.
[13:25] When the 16-year-old Dalai Lama read this agreement,
[13:28] He accepts it for the same reasons.
[13:32] The problem was that, over the next few years,
[13:35] China renegs on its promises.
[13:37] The points in the agreement were just a formality.
[13:41] In reality, China does just the opposite.
[13:44] Around 1954-55, Dalai Lama went to China for the first time,
[13:48] and was impressed with the development in China.
[13:57] Heavy industries, a well-planned transport system, good infrastructure,
[14:02] he believed that there was a lot to be learned from China.
[14:05] But he was unaware that it was all a strategy of China.
[14:09] These were the first steps of China's Re-education plans.
[14:12] During these years, the Chinese government invited
[14:15] several Tibetan officials and Tibetan citizens to witness China's development.
[14:21] To urge them to become like China.
[14:23] Several Lamas and citizens were invited
[14:26] to join their political re-education programs.
[14:28] The true purpose of these re-education plans was revealed years later.
[14:33] Mao Zedong believed in 'One Country, One Culture, One Nation'
[14:38] He was so unyielding about these things,
[14:39] he wanted the same culture all over China.
[14:43] Everyone believing in the same things.
[14:45] He couldn't tolerate any form of diversity.
[14:48] In a way, he was trying to convert people.
[14:56] In November 1956, the Dalai Lama visited India,
[15:00] and met some Tibetan freedom fighters in India.
[15:03] These freedom fighters were some guerilla warriors.
[15:05] He found out that some guerilla warriors in Tibet
[15:08] had taken up arms to try and fight against Chinese occupation.
[15:14] After talking to them, it changed Dalai Lama's perspective.
[15:17] He found out the truth about what China was doing.
[15:20] China had suppressed the freedom of the Tibetans completely.
[15:24] It wasn't a Liberalisation,
[15:27] China was colonising them.
[15:29] A large number of war crimes were committed in Tibet.
[15:31] Villages were set on fire,
[15:33] And by 1959, a proper Tibetan resistance had emerged.
[15:37] During the same time, there were constant protests in Tibet against Chinese occupation.
[15:42] New tensions were seen every day in Lhasa.
[15:45] Friends, this was the same time when the Chinese government invited Dalai Lama,
[15:50] to watch a special theatre performance in China.
[15:54] And asks him to come without his bodyguards.
[15:56] I talked about this at the beginning of the video.
[15:58] The Chinese army had surrounded Lhasa.
[16:01] The Tibetan citizens gathered outside the palace of the Dalai Lama.
[16:05] To protect the Dalai Lama.
[16:07] He had an advisory, known as the State Oracle,
[16:11] During the previous two instances when the Dalai Lama had asked the Oracle
[16:13] about what he should do,
[16:15] the Oracle had advised him to remain there and continue negotiating.
[16:20] But this time, the Oracle said, "Go, go tonight."
[16:23] He told him to flee at night to save his life.
[16:26] It was 17th March 1959,
[16:28] there was much uproar in Lhasa.
[16:31] In his autobiography, Dalai Lama mentions that
[16:34] the Oracle was meditating,
[16:37] when he suddenly grabbed a pen and made outlines on a paper,
[16:40] On the paper, he drew the escape route, explaining how and when
[16:44] the Dalai Lama should escape.
[16:46] While the Oracle was advising the Dalai Lama,
[16:48] there were two big explosions.
[16:50] Two bombs went off in Lhasa's Jewel Park.
[16:53] Dalai Lama put on a disguise and escaped from the palace.
[16:57] With him, were his mother, his sister, his younger brother, and some top officials.
[17:01] Somehow he managed to avoid the army and find his way out of the city of Lhasa.
[17:06] As soon as the Chinese government got to know about it,
[17:08] They start sending military planes.
[17:11] Search parties were sent to find out where Dalai Lama has escaped to.
[17:14] Military planes started all-day search operations
[17:17] to look for the Dalai Lama.
[17:18] And as you'd know, the Tibetian landscape is very open.
[17:22] There aren't many trees there.
[17:24] It makes it difficult for one to hide.
[17:26] In such a case, there was only one way to hide.
[17:29] Travelling only at night.
[17:31] After walking for several nights, they reached
[17:34] the Eastern Himalayan ranges.
[17:36] At one point, the Chinese military aircraft were quite close to them.
[17:40] They passed by so closely, that he was sure it was the end for them.
[17:43] Because there were no places to hide.
[17:45] But by chance, the planes did not see them,
[17:47] and passed them by.
[17:49] There weren't many culinary options on this long journey.
[17:52] They had to survive on insects.
[17:55] Remember, this was the royal family of Tibet.
[17:57] Throughout their lives, they had wonderful things to eat.
[18:01] And then suddenly, they were on a journey
[18:04] with no proper food or shelter,
[18:06] and they had to be constantly on the run.
[18:09] On this journey, they received help from an unexpected ally, the CIA.
[18:13] Yup, that's right.
[18:14] America's Central Intelligence Agency.
[18:17] CIA had already stationed its agents in India and Tibet.
[18:21] America feared that there might be a threat of World War III.
[18:24] The Cold War was underway.
[18:26] And China was an ally of the Soviet Union.
[18:29] For diplomatic reasons, India had allowed the CIA's presence.
[18:33] CIA operatives were actually training Tibetians in guerrilla warfare.
[18:39] During the people's uprising on 10th March 1958,
[18:42] CIA was aware that the Dalai Lama wasn't safe.
[18:45] CIA-trained Tibetans had built this protective force
[18:49] of the people who accompanied the Dalai Lama on this journey.
[18:52] They kept on walking for about 2 weeks.
[18:55] Walking through the perilous Himalayan range,
[18:57] they reached the last Tibetan village.
[19:00] On the Indian border.
[19:01] They could have taken a shortcut through Bhutan,
[19:03] but they didn't because of the danger of the Chinese military.
[19:06] On 26th March, upon reaching the border,
[19:09] he wrote a letter to Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru.
[19:12] In this letter, for the first time he mentions
[19:14] that he was against the Seventeen-Point Agreement.
[19:17] He explained the situation in Tibet, and his circumstances to Nehru.
[19:21] And requests asylum from Nehru.
[19:25] When Pandit Nehru read this letter,
[19:27] he immediately sent a detachment of the Assam Rifles.
[19:30] The soldiers of the Indian Army received the Dalai Lama on the border.
[19:33] And on 31st March, Dalai Lama and his group,
[19:37] entered India through Arunachal Pradesh.
[19:41] The same day, Pandit Nehru announced to the Indian Parliament,
[19:44] that the Dalai Lama should be treated with respect.
[19:46] 10th March is celebrated as the National Uprising Day
[19:50] by the Tibetans living all around the world.
[19:51] What happens to Tibet in this story?
[19:54] On 25th March 1959,
the Chinese Army entered Lhasa.
[19:58] On 28th March, the Tibetian government was dissolved.
[20:02] After that, China forces its idea of 'One Nation, One Culture' upon Tibet.
[20:08] Till 1965, CIA continued its efforts to help the Tibetan rebels.
[20:13] To support guerrilla warfare,
[20:15] so that there could be a rebellion against the Chinese army.
[20:18] So that they could fight and win.
[20:19] They are given weapons and trained,
but this remained unsuccessful.
[20:24] After America gave up, from 1966 onwards,
[20:27] Mao got the opportunity to force his agenda without any obstacles.
[20:32] From 1966 to 1976, the largest attack on the Tibetan culture was seen.
[20:38] Buddhist monasteries were destroyed.
[20:40] Cultural sites were ruined.
[20:42] During these 10 years, about 1 million Tibetans,
[20:46] were either killed, over worked, or they starved to death.
[20:50] More than 6,000 monasteries and shrines were destroyed.
[20:53] Around then, the first famines were seen in Tibet.
[20:56] A place with no famines in the recorded history up till then,
[21:00] But after the Chinese occupation,
[21:01] about 300,000 people died in the famine.
[21:05] Tibet's natural resources were terribly exploited.
[21:07] 80% of the forests were destroyed.
[21:12] The Chinese government disposed of nuclear and toxic waste in Tibet.
[21:16] As a result, the highest poverty rate even today,
[21:20] is seen in the Tibetian regions, in the entirety of China.
[21:24] 34% of the Tibetans living in the farming areas of Tibet,
[21:28] are below the poverty line.
[21:29] There have been several uprisings and revolutions in Tibet.
[21:33] But they have been unsuccessful till now.
[21:35] After the occupation, the largest protests were seen in 1987-1989.
[21:40] There was a large crowd on the road to protest.
[21:42] Martial law was declared in China.
[21:44] Foreign journalists were banned from Tibet.
[21:47] After their failure, the next major protests were in 2008.
[21:51] The protests were seen in China's Beijing Olympics,
[21:54] in these protests more than 100 Tibetans were killed,
[21:57] and more than 1,000 went missing.
[21:59] The future is even more uncertain for Tibetans.
[22:03] The Dalai Lama is 87 years old now, as of 2022.
[22:08] A frequently asked question is who will be the next Dalai Lama?
[22:12] Following the Chinese occupation it was seen that
[22:14] the two most recent Panchen Lamas,
[22:16] were appointed by the Chinese.
[22:19] The 10th Panchen Lama was appointed by the ROC,
[22:21] and the PRC selected the 11th Panchen Lama.
[22:24] In this case, China would obviously want to have the next Dalai Lama as their puppet.
[22:29] As the solution, the current Dalai Lama,
[22:31] said that it is the time to end the tradition passed down for ages.
[22:37] He says that the next Dalai Lama should be democratically elected.
[22:43] He wishes that the Tibetans would do so.
[22:46] But to have free and fair elections under the Chinese government,
[22:49] seems extremely doubtful.
[22:50] This year on 25th January,
[22:52] China had issued a directive to the workers employed
[22:55] in the Tibetian government institutions.
[22:57] To renounce the Dalai Lama and his followers.
[22:59] Today, the Chinese government says that
[23:02] Tibet's matters are China's internal matters.
[23:05] The same 'internal matter' argument that is brought up by the dictators.
[23:10] But interestingly, and you might be surprised to know,
[23:14] Tibet isn't the only area in China where this is happening.
[23:17] In China's Northwest, there's the area of Xinjiang.
[23:20] The culture over there was distinct from the rest of China.
[23:23] More than 1 million Uyghur Muslims over there,
[23:26] have been put into 're-education camps.'
[23:28] The same thing that's being done to the Tibetans.
[23:30] In the East, China is trying to do the same in Hong Kong.
[23:34] The people in Hong Kong want democracy, they want to be liberal,
[23:38] but the Chinese beliefs are being imposed over there.
[23:40] Additionally, China also claims Taiwan to be theirs.
[23:43] So overall, in the places that have a different culture,
[23:46] this Chinese policy is being forced.
[23:48] On the Buddhists in Tibet.
[23:50] On the Uyghur Muslims.
[23:52] On the people of Hong Kong in the East.
[23:54] It is hoped that the Chinese government would someday weaken,
[23:59] and these regions will launch a joint revolution against their dictatorship.
[24:04] To win their freedom.
[24:06] One good thing is that,
[24:07] at least the Tibetans are treated well in India.
[24:11] All Indian governments have been very helpful to the Tibetan refugees.
[24:15] Back in the 1960s, the Karnataka government
[24:18] had allocated 3,000 acres of land
to create the first Tibetian-exile settlement.
[24:23] Apart from this, in Delhi's Majnu Ka Tilla,
[24:26] the land was allocated for the Tibetan refugees.
[24:29] Today, there are more than 150,000 Tibetan refugees in India.
[24:33] Though they have not been offered Indian citizenship,
[24:36] and their status can be revoked at any time.
[24:38] But they are temporarily living a peaceful life.
[24:42] If you liked the video,
[24:43] click here to watch more such videos
[24:46] on major historical topics.
[24:47] Thank you very much!